19 Comments
User's avatar
Joseph Kaplan's avatar

Do you really have to write to respond to those idiots? Netanyahu said it clearly in his speech yesterday. If someone says they are going to kill you believe them.

Expand full comment
Julian Paul Zukmann's avatar

Everything Goldberg says is true.

But and it’s an enormous imperative

conditional to make it real now,

our time. Which is that Israel must conduct nothing less than

an all out Annihilating War on Iran: reducing it to. and it must use EMP and Nuclear Weapons to achieve the actuality of

this unconditional victory it must have to guarantee its survival and future

Existence.

This is absolutely not what Netanyahu and his woke generals have done and have utterly failed to do. And failed Israel and the Jewish people of the world to be do. They are completely incapable of bringing it because They are governed by an irrational, appeasing, degenerate woke regressive fantasy of managing

implacable enemies as morality-which endlessly goes on sacrificing Jewish

lives as a virtue signaling offering to the Jew Hating world in order to garner

their all important approval, to prevent at all costs their fear driven fantasy of

the unbearable consequences of disapproval. And could never be borne.

And is the true existential threat-this emotional rejectionism of the

world rather than the oncoming nuclear physical annihilation of our

enemies. Therefore in combination with their conviction of Virtue signaling self sacrifice and approval seeking as the highest morality, it is

unthinkable for them, and makes them absolutely unfit as leaders of

The Jewish People, who are commanded to Annihilate the Amalekites

reappearing in every age for the last three thousand years.

The terrible bloviating fraud Netanyahu has not gone away at

last nor been transformed into all out destroying warrior Israel

must have. He has merely pulled off his crowning publicity stunt

a completely non strategic, non determinative, non decisive

phony war on a massive, genocidal relentless metastasizing

force, making a political show of “managing” it, leaving it alive to

grow back, do anything but take on the obligation to destroy it.

The absolute proof of everything I’m saying is he now has the Jewish

People of Israel and the world wondering and waiting for what the

Nature of Iran’s counter attack will be. Rather than having absolutely

destroyed them as must be done, and he has traitorously left open

remaining to be done, there would not be anything left of Iran to

make a counter arrack.

have done with their disastrous limited, self defeating

“precision, targeted strike” on the multidimensional, psychotic

Jew Genociding, transnational monster of Iran. None of

the mutiple super hardened, deep mountain buried (Frowdo)

Nuclear armed ICBM infrastructure sites Can be allowed to survive.

The Ayatollah must be eliminated

Killed not merely some of his lieutenant commanders and some of

the nuclear scientists. But absolutely all of the political, military and

academic establishment must be wiped out, at whatever cost to the

so called civilian population in which they are embedded makes no

difference whatsoever if Annihilating Strategic unconditional victory

Over this genocidal Judeophobic, psychotic regime

Expand full comment
jrs's avatar

…Or maybe, just maybe, Netanyahu—because he is vastly more experienced, savvy, patient, smart & adept at juggling 15 different important considerations at once than you are—had an actual plan to attack Iran in the way that will be the most effective.

You think?

You’re not altogether wrong about what you call woke influence—but would better be described here as a ridiculous penchant for waiting, over-cautiousness & endless negotiation— has seeped even into the higher echelons of the IDF. Netanyahu knows this better than you—he has to deal with, and around, those types.

But angrily dismissing Netanyahu & any other decision-maker that doesn’t stomp around calling for dropping bombs the moment you think it would be a good idea is infantile thinking.

Thank God Israel has a remarkably stalwart, brilliant, laser-focused (tho of course not perfect) leader in its current PM…

…rather than the kind of sincere but arrogant hotheads who read a few articles & foolishly think their passionate opinions about & loyalty to Israel mean they know not just how to run a country, but how to conduct a multi-front war.

Expand full comment
Richard Redstone's avatar

I agree with a lot of what you say. In a perfect world Israel and Netanyahu would do exactly what you set forth as a solution. But Israel doesn’t have the powerful bombs or the right airplanes to take out Frowdo. Therefore they are dependent on the U.S. to supply Israel with the correct armaments or persuade Trump to act in unison. Also, there is a good chance China would get involved in this war if their ability to get “discounted” oil from Iran because of U.S. sanctions is threatened… which is the very reason Israel hasn’t blown up Iran’s oil fields. When considering nuclear options Israel has to consider unintended consequences.. unfortunately.

Expand full comment
Julian Paul Zukmann's avatar

Israel does have the bombs and the planes but absolutely none of the leadership to use

Them. China’s loss is at least

in the mainstream U.S. narrative, as it’s “chief enemy”-

U.S. gain. And in any case

existentially Israel must do

what it must, letting the

Chips fall where they may.

Fearlessly following GOD’S

Torah commanded will

Expand full comment
Surak's avatar

No, Israel has fighters, but not bombers. They have asked America for bombers and, shamefully, have been turned down. Richard is correct.

Expand full comment
jrs's avatar

People who insist they know precisely what is “God’s commanded will”—particularly about hugely complex geopolitical issues—are often the most dangerous, and dangerously delusional ones.

One can be thoroughly religious & fully observant— and nevertheless acknowledge the obvious reality that not everything you—or even a learned & sincere rabbi—think is the right thing to do is God whispering in your ear.

Sometimes it’s just an opinion.

Expand full comment
EKB's avatar

Did you really have to put a picture of that kapo on your page? Seeing his name is enough to make me want to retch

Expand full comment
Reality Seeker's avatar

Lots of people don’t know who Peter Beinart is. A picture along with information is good because he is a totally dangerous asxhole.

Expand full comment
DEMedia is Propaganda's avatar

Zukmann Wrong. Redstone Correct.

Netanyahu is the greatest world leader since the American founders.

There have been another great ones but none of had to deal with what Netanyahu has to both internally and externally.

The USA is sadly an unreliable ally. Even with a GOP President because Trump is fake GOP, Fake Christian,.Fake conservative.

He totally betrayed Israel May 2024 with his bribery tour of the Middle East.

He skipped Israel. Admitted deal with the hoodies to stop attacking ships but left Israel out of it and Israel has been attacked ever since.

Trump advance need to be impeached removed prosecuted and legally executed along with a lot more in Trump circle and the same for leaders of the collectivist Party and ecosystem

We have proposed to Constitutional amendment to facilitate this by ex post facto removing all pardons immunities please and statute of limitations

Expand full comment
jrs's avatar

You started off making a good point—namely, that the other guy was off the rails in his hysterical rant against pretty much the entire Israeli government!—and then you jumped right off the rails behind him, going to the other extreme.

Trump’s a relentless zigging & zagging is confusing and frustrating. And yes, at times, can seem detrimental to Israel’s interests. But each time he more or less came through when it mattered most—as he is doing now, with Israel’s remarkable attack on Iran.

That doesn’t cancel out the moments where he fails to really stand with Israel convincingly.

But consistency, predictability & even displays of loyalty are not his strong points—no one ever said they are. Probably Trump himself wouldn’t say that.

You can dislike the man’s habits & tactics, without going wildly over the top with talk of impeachment etc.

Is this some new breed of bot— historical, melodramatic rants, instead of robotic phrases? Or are there just a lot of people here who think in Binary—everyone is either evil or a hero, utterly, Divinely right… or criminally wrong?

Expand full comment
AJoy's avatar

Wow 😮

Expand full comment
Julian Paul Zukmann's avatar

You’ve no idea what you’re

talking about. Though you’re

right about Trump’s total

Jihadi slobbering, open multi

trillion dollar “betrayal” of

Israel, he is only following the

Playbook of every other U.S.

president in one guise or

another. Since Truman first

conceded to “recognize”

Israel in 1948, but immediately

Placed an absolute U.S.

Embargo on selling it any

weapons.

Beyond that your Trump Derangement Syndrome

Kicks in you lose all touch with reality. As his domestic

policies, though completely

inadequate are at least a nominal attempt: beyond

sealing the border, to deport

some few thousands of the many

tens of millions of invading non

white, third world; Muslim,

African, Arab, CCP Chinese

Hispanic, South and Central

American illegal alien, nation

destroying parasites, we now

have tearing the National fabric apart. Believing they own and will destroy the

Constitutional Republic.

These primitive I.Q. Savages

must be hurled out or white

European and Ashkenazi Jewish America will not survive.

Now as far as Israel is concerned. It must at last grow up and become a truly autonomous sovereign nation

freeing itself of all U.S. interactive dependency, and

fearlessly using Jewish Genius to vastly expand its full arsenal

Nuclear, Conventional and Laser weapons to expand geo strategically, geopolitically, and territorially, from the Nile to Euphrates, rebuild the third

temple, expel all Arabs from

within Israel, and evolve from a

beleaguered defensive Jewish ghetto state. Into one of the

greatest powers on Earth. Which is its destiny.

There, I fixed you for you.

Though as Sigmund said

first presenting the patient with reality will only massively

grow his resistance and so one must increasingly hit him with more and more.

Expand full comment
jrs's avatar

OK, that’s enough.

You’re either a bot meant to parody RW extremists, or a weird Lefty aiming for some sort of multi-layered satirical statement…or you’re completely unhinged, and need to get back on your medication, ASAP.

Expand full comment
Alan, aka DudeInMinnetonka's avatar

Nick Fuentes is this klafte's brother from another mother👀

both have that inbred shrunken fetal alcohol syndrome mug

I see McGregor & kiddy diddler Scott Ritter are still on that boulevard of blow hard circuit 🤦🏿‍♀️

Expand full comment
Reality Seeker's avatar

Thanks for this succinct, important post. Lots of people are not aware of these two idiots and their incredibly delusional and dangerous rhetoric. Unfortunately, too many other idiots listen to them.

Expand full comment
Not so young anymore.'s avatar

Really those two are such fools it’s time for both of them to sit down and shut up. Why they think they have something to say is beyond me.

Expand full comment
Stan's avatar

Right on, Bob.

Expand full comment
DEMedia is Propaganda's avatar

Scum like Beinarr deserve Legal Torture Execution. We have proposed a Constitutional Amendment to Allow for the Worst of the Worst.

Expand full comment